By
Chris Holmes Staff Writer
Updated

Spectrum vs CenturyLink

Article Summary

Spectrum and CenturyLink are two titans of internet service in the United States. (Charter) Spectrum is available in 43 states, while CenturyLink is present in 37 (and counting). If you're in the market for an internet plan, there's a better than average chance that you've come across one of these companies in your search. 

Given this, we thought it high time we compared Spectrum and CenturyLink's costs, availability, customer reviews and bundles.

Spectrum vs CenturyLink

Spectrum vs. CenturyLink: Internet Speeds


Winner: CenturyLink

If you're looking for lightning-fast internet speeds, CenturyLink is a better bet than Spectrum: the provider's fiber plans offer an amazing 1 Gbps. The rest of the CenturyLink's plans deliver roughly 100 Mbps speeds and below, via VDSL connections. 

Spectrum's cable internet plans, meanwhile, top out at 100 Mbps. Granted, cable internet is more commonly available than fiber (it's also very reliable, but that's a discussion for another time) since it makes use of the nation's existing cable TV infrastructure. In any event, the clear victor when it comes to speed is CenturyLink. 

Cost, Data and Value for Money


Winner: Spectrum

Monthly Cost

Spectrum's cable internet plans are all around $45 for 100 Mbps—not a bad deal, incidentally—and go up in price as you start adding bundling options. The company's most expensive package is the $139.97 100 Mbps internet/Gold TV/Phone service. 

While $45 gets you 100 Mbps from Spectrum, that same price only gets you 10 Mbps with CenturyLink. It costs an additional $20—bringing the monthly cost to $65—for 100 Mbps speeds from the provider.

The cost round goes to Spectrum.

Data Allowance

Data caps can be a real bummer to worry about. To Spectrum's credit, their plans all come data cap-free. CenturyLink meanwhile, caps their plans at 1,000 GB/month. It should be said that 1,000 GB is a massive amount; but still.

Availability: Spectrum vs. CenturyLink


Winner: Spectrum

In terms of overall availability, Spectrum's coverage area is a bit broader than CenturyLink's; as mentioned, Spectrum's internet plans are available in 43 states, while CenturyLink's are available in 37. Given this, we'll declare Spectrum the winner here. 

Customer Reviews: Spectrum vs. CenturyLink


Winner: Spectrum and CenturyLink 


If online reviews are to be believed, both Spectrum and CenturyLink have ample room for improvement when it comes to keeping their customers happy (although, bear in mind that internet providers are generally the most widely derided in the United States). Customers cited Spectrum's rising costs and slower than advertised connections as their reasons for unhappiness, while CenturyLink customers complained about frequent service outages and slow speeds.

JD Power's annual residential internet service provider customer satisfaction study tells a slightly different tale. The 2018 study puts Spectrum near the top in certain regions (it's divided according to four of them), with the east coast the only place the provider earns less than 3 "power cicles." CenturyLink, meanwhile, either does not show on the leader board or comes in with a meager 2 stars, in the south and west.

It's hard to take either of these metrics as gospel, however, so we'll declare this round a toss-up.

Bundle Packages: Spectrum vs CenturyLink


Winner: CenturyLink

While both Spectrum and CenturyLink offer a wide assortment of double and triple play bundles, i.e. internet + phone or TV, a look through WhistleOut's comparison engine indicates that CenturyLink has more configurations and tiers.

This makes it easier to get exactly what you're looking for in internet, TV and phone service with CenturyLink, and the reason we're declaring the provider the winner in this category.

Winner: Spectrum vs CenturyLink


Winner: Spectrum and CenturyLink 


In this head-to-head between two of the nation's largest ISPs, CenturyLink wins on speed and bundling options, Spectrum wins on cost and coverage, and the providers tie with respect to customer reviews. As such, we'll have to declare this battle of titans a toss-up. 

In the end, the best provider for you relates to your specific needs and wants as a customer. Are you looking to save a few bucks by getting a slower plan, or are you willing to shell out top dollar for blazing fast speeds? Do you want more coverage options, or is the reliability of the connection type of utmost concern? 

Whatever your preferences, at least you can go into your internet plan search with your eyes open regarding the strengths and weaknesses of Spectrum and CenturyLink. 

Spectrum Internet Plans

#1
Spectrum
Spectrum

Internet Premier

  • Cable 500/20 Mbps
  • Unlimited Data
$50/mo
($40 plan + $10 modem)
for 1 year
+ $20 Upfront
#2
Spectrum
Spectrum

Internet Premier + Spectrum Unlimited Plus

  • Cable 500/20 Mbps
  • Unlimited Data
$60/mo
($40 plan + $20 modem)
for 1 year
+ $20 Upfront
#3
Spectrum
Spectrum

Internet Gig

  • Cable 1000/35 Mbps
  • Unlimited Data
$70/mo
($60 plan + $10 modem)
for 1 year
+ $20 Upfront
#4
Spectrum
Spectrum

Internet Gig + Spectrum Mobile

  • Cable 1000/35 Mbps
  • Unlimited Data
$70/mo
($60 plan + $10 modem)
for 1 year
+ $20 Upfront

CenturyLink Internet Plans

CenturyLink
CenturyLink

Simply Unlimited 140 Mbps

  • VDSL 140/20 Mbps
  • Unlimited Data
$55/mo
Available in select locations. Paperless billing required.
CenturyLink
CenturyLink

Simply Unlimited 100 Mbps

  • VDSL 100/10 Mbps
  • Unlimited Data
$55/mo
Available in select locations. Paperless billing required.
CenturyLink
CenturyLink

Simply Unlimited 80 Mbps

  • VDSL 80/10 Mbps
  • Unlimited Data
$55/mo
Available in select locations. Paperless billing required.
+ $149 Upfront
CenturyLink
CenturyLink

Simply Unlimited 60 Mbps

  • VDSL 60/5 Mbps
  • Unlimited Data
$55/mo
Available in select locations. Paperless billing required.
+ $149 Upfront
CenturyLink
CenturyLink

Simply Unlimited 40 Mbps

  • VDSL 40/3 Mbps
  • Unlimited Data
$55/mo
Available in select locations. Paperless billing required.
+ $25 Upfront
CenturyLink
CenturyLink

Simply Unlimited 30 Mbps

  • VDSL 30/1.5 Mbps
  • Unlimited Data
$55/mo
Available in select locations. Paperless billing required.
+ $25 Upfront
CenturyLink
CenturyLink

Simply Unlimited 15 Mbps

  • VDSL 15/0.75 Mbps
  • Unlimited Data
$55/mo
Available in select locations. Paperless billing required.
+ $25 Upfront
CenturyLink
CenturyLink

Simply Unlimited 10 Mbps

  • VDSL 10/1 Mbps
  • Unlimited Data
$55/mo
Available in select locations. Paperless billing required.
+ $25 Upfront
CenturyLink
CenturyLink

Simply Unlimited 6 Mbps

  • VDSL 6/0.5 Mbps
  • Unlimited Data
$55/mo
Available in select locations. Paperless billing required.
+ $25 Upfront
CenturyLink
CenturyLink

Simply Unlimited 3 Mbps

  • VDSL 3/0.5 Mbps
  • Unlimited Data
$55/mo
Available in select locations. Paperless billing required.
+ $25 Upfront

Chris Holmes

Staff Writer

Chris Holmes
Chris Holmes is a Contributing Writer for WhistleOut, where he covers the cell phone and internet industries. His work has been cited in publications like The Verge, The New York Times, and WIRED.

Read full bio


Find a Better Internet Plan

Compare providers available in your area.

Search 48 Providers

Compare broadband plans from the following providers...